Commenting AP journalist Brian Murphy’s article in which he gives misleading information about Kerkuk

April 27, 2009 at 12:17 pm | Posted in Turkmens | Leave a comment
Tags: , , , , ,


Journalist Brian Murphy is misleading his readers when he writes : “The northern city is a fault line between the majority Kurds and Arabs, but also includes ethnic Turks and various Christian groups”

For many centuries Kerkuk has been the Turkmens’ capital city and main cultural centre in Iraq, Turkmens are not an insignificant minority in the city as implied in Brian Murphy’s article.

If Brian Murphy had done his homework he would know that Kurds are newcomers in Kerkuk.  They were settled in Kerkuk by the Kurdish warlords Barzani and Talabani to change the demography of the city.

The largest demographical change happened since 2003 when over 600.000 Kurds were brought to Kerkuk and surrounding Turkmen towns. The majority of these immigrant Kurds had not been evicted from the city by the Baath regime, they came from Iran, Syria and other parts of Northern Iraq.

In April 2003 Kerkuk had 750.000 inhabitants, today it has over 1.35 million inhabitants, and all the newcomers are Kurds!

Kurds pretend that Kerkuk is “historically Kurdish”!!!  If that is the case, where are their monuments? Where are the historical traces of their presence in Kerkuk?

Many monuments demonstrate the long history of the Turkmens in the north of Iraq, in his book  “The Urban Fabric and Traditional Houses of KERKUK” (see details at the top of the page under “Books“) Dr. Suphi Saatçi documents the contributions made by Turkmens to the field of residential architecture.


Above: Gök Kumbet (photo Karakoyunlu82)


Above: Traditional Turkmen house in Kerkuk Castle (photo by Karakoyunlu82)

Since the invasion and occupation of Iraq by the US-led coalition Kurds have been trying to include oil rich Kerkuk into their Kurdistan region,  they have imposed their hegemony over the entire north of Iraq by force, against the will of the Turkmens who are the second most important ethnic community in the north of Iraq.

It should be noted that the other ethnic groups in the north of Iraq:  the Arabs, the Assyrians, the Shabaks and the Yezidis, also oppose Kurdish hegemony.

Iraq: US raid ‘crime’ that breaks security pact

By BRIAN MURPHY, Associated Press Writer Brian Murphy, Associated Press Writer

BAGHDAD – Iraq’s prime minister denounced a deadly U.S. raid on Sunday as a “crime” that violated the security pact with Washington and demanded American commanders hand over those responsible to face possible trial in Iraqi courts.


The U.S., however, strongly denied that it overstepped its bounds and said it notified Iraqi authorities in advance — in accordance with the rules that took effect this year governing U.S. battlefield conduct. military

The pre-dawn raid in the southern Shiite city of Kut ended with at least one woman dead after being caught in gunfire and six suspects arrested for alleged links to Shiite militia factions.

But efforts were quickly launched in an attempt to tone down the dispute.

The six detainees were released, said Major Gen. Read Shakir Jawdat, head of the provincial police that includes Kut. At the same news conference, U.S. Col. Richard Francey offered condolences to the family of the woman killed.

The fallout marks the most serious test of the security pact so far and could bring new strains during a critical transition period.

U.S. forces plan to move out of most major Iraqi cities by the end of June in the first phase of a promised withdrawal from the country by the end of 2011.

A statement from Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki — in his role as commander general of Iraqi forces — called the raid a “violation of the security pact.”

He asked the U.S. military “to release the detainees and hand over those responsible for this crime to the courts,” according to an Iraqi security official who read the statement to The Associated Press.

Elsewhere in Iraq, gunmen stormed two Christian homes in separate attacks in the ethnically diverse city of Kirkuk, killing at least two Chaldean Christians and one Assyrian, said police Brig. Burham Taib.

The northern city is a fault line between the majority Kurds and Arabs, but also includes ethnic Turks and various Christian groups. A U.N. report given to Iraqi leaders last week recommends giving Kirkuk a “special status” with oversight by both the Kurd region and the central government in Baghdad.

In Kut, the cascade of protests and questions began just hours after the sweep into Kut, which the U.S. military said targeted suspected backers of Shiite militias believed to have links to Iran.

Hundreds of demonstrators gathered at the mosque in Kut, about 100 miles (160 kilometers) southeast of Baghdad, to decry the American action and demand an investigation.

The provincial council then called an emergency meeting and a three-day mourning period. The Iraqi Defense Ministry also ordered the arrest of two high-ranking Iraqi officers for their alleged roles in allowing U.S. forces to operate in Kut.

“We condemn this crime,” said Mahmoud al-Etaibi, head of the council.

Iraq‘s military spokesman, Maj. Gen. Qassim al-Moussawi, described it as the “first violation after signing the security pact.”

The U.S. military said its troops acted within the framework of the security pact, saying “the operation was fully coordinated and approved by the Iraqi government.”

The accord, which took effect Jan. 1, requires American commanders to coordinate raids and other pre-planned strikes with the Iraqi government and military, or work in joint U.S.-Iraq units.

At least one person died in the raid, which the U.S. military said targeted the financier of Shiite militia factions believed to be backed by the Iranians. Iraqi officials placed the death toll at two.

The Defense Ministry spokesman, Mohammed al-Askari, said an Iraqi brigade commander and a battalion commander were arrested for “allowing American troops to conduct a military operation in Kut province without informing the Iraqi government or coordinating with it.”

Kut provincial police chief, Brig. Gen. Raed Shakir Jawdat, said he was unaware a raid was conducted. The U.S. military did not provide information on whether Iraqi security forces took part.

The military said a woman was in the area during an exchange of gunfire with one of the suspects and “stepped into the line of fire.”

It said those detained were suspected of aiding so-called “special groups” — Shiite militia factions that were once part of the Mahdi Army of anti-American cleric Moqtada al-Sadr — and another faction known as the Promise Day Brigades created by al-Sadr.

Washington says the special groups are backed by Iran. Tehran denies the charges.

Iraqi police officials say the wife and brother of a local clan leader were killed. They also say the soldiers arrested the clan leader, Ahmed Abdul Muneim al-Bdeir, his brother — an Iraqi police captain — and five others related to the al-Bdeir.

The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not allowed to release the information.


Associated Press Writer Chelsea J. Carter and Qassim Abdul-Zahra contributed to this report.


Leave a Comment »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: